|
Roads in the so-called Lost Provinces in 1936. You will note that state highways 113 and 93, mentioned in the post, do not yet exist. 113 probably replaced the unimproved road (light blue dots) that led from Laurel Springs and crossed US 221 near Scottville. When the roads were regraded and paved, the road from that point to the Virginia line was designated highway 93. Highway 16, from the crest of the Blue Ridge to Wilkesboro, is shown as a gravel road. County maps from this year show it as paved. The inconsistency suggests that this stretch of road was paved in that year. Source: NC State Highway Map, 1936. Website: Digitized Historical Maps: Georeferenced Historical NC Maps. The repository of this map is the North Carolina State Archives. My parents were born in Ashe and Alleghany counties, two adjoining counties in the northwest corner of North Carolina. By the time I was aware of my grandparents—my father’s parents and my mother’s mother (her father had been killed in 1938)—they lived near each other on Federal highway 221 and ran country stores. “Federal highway” sounds grand, but it was a winding, narrow road, noticeably crown shaped, with narrow shoulders. In my small world, it was the road that connected three significant places: Sparta, the county seat of Alleghany County; Scottville, the unincorporated community straddling Alleghany and Ashe where my grandparents lived on the Alleghany side; and Jefferson, county seat of Ashe County, where my family would live for roughly 18 months when I was in the fifth and sixth grades. Between Sparta and Scottville was the turnoff to a road (unpaved when I was a child) that led to my paternal grandfather’s cattle farm, tobacco allotment, and strawberry patches, and beyond to Peach Bottom Mountain. My paternal grandfather Elbert (far right; 1901 – 1972, K63B-274 [1]), his sons, and one grandson at the old Duncan Place on highway 113 just northwest of its intersection with 221. This picture was taken around the time of the Korean War. My father is in the middle wearing a dark shirt and light trousers. My maternal grandmother was Anyce (1897 –1990, K46N-3JD); in her later years everyone called her Mama Shepherd. Her store was separated from 221 by two gas pumps (she sold Shell gas) and a space alongside the highway just wide enough for a car safely to park to buy gas. Once, in a management training program, I was mentored by a retired executive from the petroleum industry. He said his claim to fame was the invention of the self-service gas station. I replied that my grandmother had invented it long before him. “If you want gas, pump it yourself” she told new customers who stopped to gas up; her regulars didn’t have to be told. She sat in a recliner in a small living room just off the equally small storeroom. Aside from the recliner, there were a small couch, tables with begonias and violets and a table clock, and on the wall the pictures of her patron saints—FDR, her late husband Charlie (murdered in 1938), and superimposed profiles of the slain Kennedy brothers that had been pulled from an issue of Look Magazine and framed. When regular customers who had filled up came in to pay, she often told them to put the money on the counter. (This was a long time before you could pay at the pump.) She allowed the most trusted customers to make change from her cash box. The store my father’s parents ran was bigger than Anyce’s and sold a wider variety of goods. In addition to the canned goods, sodas, and snack foods my grandmother stocked, they sold engine belts, salt blocks for cattle, sacks of feed, denim outerwear. The stock was delivered by truck, of course, over the two-lane highways. Mom turned 5 shortly after her father was killed; she befriended many of the delivery men. She once gave the Dr Pepper man a puppy, and in return he gave her a free soda every week. Near Anyce’s store NC highway 113 crosses 221 and runs north till it merges with NC 93 and continues across the New River in Mouth of Wilson, Virginia. Till I was 11, we lived in Marion, Virginia, but came to visit the grandparents virtually every weekend. I became intimately familiar with 113 and with Virginia highway 16 which connected Mouth of Wilson to Marion. Later, when we moved to Jefferson, NC, I learned that Virginia 16 became NC 16 at the state line and provided a direct route from Jefferson to Marion. When we moved to Wilkes County, to visit the grandparents we drove north on NC highway 18 to climb the Blue Ridge; in Laurel Springs, about twelve miles short of Sparta, we turned northwest on our friend NC 113 till we reached its intersection with US 221. This stretch of Highway 18 was, and is, a winding road, with a 270 degree hairpin turn. Daddy said the highway builders chose its course by following a cow on her way up the mountain. Mama Shepherd behind the counter of her store. Her elbow rests on worn linoleum on top of the counter; visible behind her are canned food—possibly pork and beans—and packs of cigarettes. I risk this long account of highways because, having traveled them hundreds of times in my life, they are deeply familiar and hold a place of deep affection. They were there when I came along and I found it natural to imagine they have always been there. But such is not the case. The corner of the state where my parents were born did not get reliable, all-weather roads connecting them to the foothills and piedmont of North Carolina until after 1921, when the State Highway Act became law, in part as a result of lobbying by the Good Roads movement. (Hugh Talmage Lefler and Albert Ray Newsome, North Carolina: The History of a Southern State. Revised Edition, UNC, 1963, 554; see also “Good Roads Movement.”) This was just five years before my father was born. Until then, the roads connecting the rest of the state to the northwest corner were sketchy at best. In 1915, in his A History of Watauga County, John Preston Arthur, wrote: “The mountain can be easily passed at each of these gaps [in the Blue Ridge escarpment], and, if the roads were good, the inconvenience of crossing the mountain would be disregarded. The roads have been badly laid out; they are badly made, and the population in many parts is too weak to keep the roads in even tolerable repair.” This essay is about the isolation of the area and how the term “Lost Provinces” came to be applied to it. The obstacles to building good roads connecting the Lost Provinces to the rest of the state were geographic, political, and economic. Geographic. In 1924, a report issued by the State Ship and Water Transportation Commission stated: “North Carolina is in a tragic condition of being itself dismembered and of having most of the communications of its people north and south instead of east and west, and it has been made as difficult as possible for the people of the east and the people of the west to trade with each other. And thus it is that we have ‘lost provinces’ in the west and ‘lost provinces’ in the east.” (Report of the State Ship and Water Transportation Commission, 1924, 11. ECU Digital Collections) The roads in the Lost Provinces in 1924. The roads leading down the mountain from Boone and Jefferson to Wilkesboro and from Sparta to Elkin were more trail than road. (Map: Report of the State Ship and Water Transportation Commission.) In this period, as discussed below, young Edwin Duncan would hike from Doughton to Sparta when he returned home from university in Chapel Hill because, for practical purposes, the road didn’t exist. The barrier to movement to the northwest corner was the Blue Ridge escarpment. In the late 18th century, settlers and travelers—many were passing through the North Carolina mountains on the way to settle in Kentucky—discovered that the Blue Ridge could be ascended via narrow passes called gaps. (These gaps include Cook’s Gap, Phillips’ Gap, Deep Gap, Flat Gap, Daniel’s Gap, Reddies River Gap, and Mulberry Gap.) The problem was climbing up to the gaps from the lowland, especially when pulling wagons. Once the Blue Ridge had been climbed, travelers “found to their surprise that the Blue Ridge was a ridge on the eastern side but not ridge at all on the west. They found themselves standing on the edge of a vast plateau, stretching west, southwest and northwest as far as their eyes could see. Rolling woodlands of fairly uniform height lay before them and from the woodlands rose here and there lofty mountains, four thousand to five thousand feet above sea level” (Arthur Lloyd Fletcher, Ashe County: A History, New Edition, McFarland, 1963, 2006, 61-62). Before the roads down the mountain were graded and paved, those who lived in the mountains and had goods to buy or sell found it easier to go to the railheads in Johnson City, Tennessee; Marion, Virginia (later Troutdale, around 20 miles closer than Marion); and Galax, Virginia. In 1914, the railroad came to West Jefferson, Ashe County, but it came in from the north (“The Virginia Creeper in West Jefferson”) so still did not provide direct transportation to the rest of the state. As of 1890, a spur line from Winston-Salem terminated in North Wilkesboro, but according to the lore of a friend’s family, it took an oxcart a day and a half to drive the forty miles from Jefferson to Wilkesboro, and another day and a half to make the return trip (“North Carolina Railroads - North-Western North Carolina Railroad”). My father told my brother that it took three days to make the round trip to North Wilkesboro from Ashe County with a horse and wagon—one day to get there and two days to go back. Climbing the mountain was hard on the horses. (See the comment section for more.) Traveling to railheads in West Jefferson, Tennessee, and Virginia was easier and less expensive than traveling down the mountain to North Wilkesboro, but only the depot there offered direct passenger and freight service to the piedmont and eastern NC. Political and Economic. Until the passage of the 1921 law, road building and maintenance were generally left to the counties. They were some exceptions: a turnpike was laboriously built from the Tennessee line in Ashe County to Wilkesboro using private, county, and state funds as well as tolls paid by travelers; it was “a sand-clay road, with improved grades” (Fletcher, 100). It was destroyed in the 1916 flood and then abandoned. The mountain counties were settled too sparsely to provide the manpower needed to build and maintain roads, especially in the demanding terrain of the Blue Ridge front. (The 1916 flood also destroyed a branch railroad, the Watauga and Yadkin Valley line, that ran 24 miles from North Wilkesboro to Darby. It was built to haul timber out of the foothills. There were plans, likely unrealistic, to continue the line to Boone, about 1,600 feet higher in elevation than Darby and 2,100 feet higher than North Wilkesboro (“No ‘Alleged’ Railroad,” The North Wilkesboro Hustler, 29 July 1913). While he was in his teens, my first father-in-law, Talmadge, took the train to Darby then walked the remaining 20 miles to Boone, so he could attend summer classes at Appalachian Training School (now Appalachian State University) and qualify to teach in the public schools. The W&Y Railroad is still shown on the 1924 map above, but by then it existed only in the form of wrecked locomotives and ruined trestles. By then the dream of building railroads into the mountains had been replaced by ambitions of building all-weather roads.) Several changes led to the Highway Act of 1921—the formation of the State Highway Commission by the legislature in 1915, the Federal Highway Act of 1916 providing funds to the states “on a matching basis to improve major interstate federal roads,” and state laws enacted in 1917 allowing the State Highway Commission to accept federal funds and to impose automobile license fees (Lefler and Newsome, 554). Life in a Lost Province Over the years, I’ve gathered a few stories, from my family and others—illustrating how the folks in the mountain were affected by the isolation and their transportation choices. Dave and Lou Tisha Grubb. Dave (1870–1957, KN98-77L) and Lou Tisha (1880–1960, KN98-WHH) were my father’s maternal grandparents. Beginning around 1926, they lived near Nathan’s Creek, Ashe County, on a farm still in the family. In 1926, Dave bought the farm from Lou Tisha’s father, John Shepherd (1849 – 1926, LZ8H-XQ2), who died that year. I don’t know how long the farm had been in the family. I understand that the house was built in the 1850s by Barnett V. Idol and, so far as I know, it was already owned by the Shepherd family. (Conversation with Nancy Bare, 11/22/2020) Dave and Lou Tisha Grubb in the fall of 1925. Great Aunt Maude (1910–1993, L8Q8-65D), my grandmother’s sister, once briefly described life on the farm in the 30s and 40s. Her mother raised wonderful peaches, she told me, clingstone varieties in June and July for pies and sweet pickles, Albertas in August and September for canning. The family milked 10 to 12 cows, and with the milk they fed the hogs, gave skim milk to the neighbors, and made butter, cottage cheese, and some solid cheese. (Conversation with Maude Lowman, 4/1/1979) As to travel, she mentioned only that her father Dave took wheat, rye, and buckwheat by wagon to be ground by the mill in Mouth of Wilson, Virginia. The trip, about 15 miles mostly by highway 16, now takes fewer than 20 minutes by car, more than five hours on foot. To reach the mill on Wilson Creek, he had to cross the New River by ferry. When I was quite young, the river was still crossed by ferry. I don’t remember the ferry, but I do recall the narrow truss bridge that succeeded it and was not replaced with a modern suspension bridge till well into my adult years. One of the more dramatic family stories was first told to me by my dad, but my cousin Becky, daughter of John R. Grubb, shared with me a more complete and probably more accurate version in a conversation in June 2018. In 1920, John R. Grubb (1902–1993, KN98-WKX) rode a horse into church during service. He was 17 and his purpose was to see a young lady at the service. He had called out to her from outside, but she wouldn’t come out to see him—she was sitting by another young man. John rode in to see her. In addition to being filled with the foolishness of youth, he may well have been full of drink, or so my father heard. He got into a fight in the church, and in the melee, someone cut off his necktie just under the knot. He never wore a necktie again. As my father told it, disturbing the peace inside a church was a serious offence. To avoid his arrest, he said, that night Dave Grubb took his son by horseback to Troutdale, Virginia, where he put him on a train for California. The depot in West Jefferson was only about half as far as Troutdale, but perhaps Dave wanted to get out of the state as soon as possible while avoiding local officers of the law. Becky’s version is a little less dramatic and more detailed: a day or two after the event (but not the same night), Dave rode with John to the railhead in Troutdale and sent him to West Virginia to stay with family and work in the mines. The mines wouldn't hire him—he was too young—so he moved on to Macallister, Oklahoma, where he also had family. He worked for a couple of years and saved money to take the train to California.[2] Family already in California helped him find work, and until the Depression John did well working for two men, Mr. Lewis and another man, and I believe he had his own small spread. When the Depression hit, John was married with three children, one of whom suffered from epilepsy. Eventually, his employers could no longer pay their help—poor Mr. Lewis killed himself—and for a while John and his family got by on a barn full of sweet potatoes. John R. Grubb in California In the depths of the Depression, around 1938 (I think), John Grubb and his family returned to North Carolina permanently. It took 12 days just to cross Texas, Becky said, with her mother driving (John R. didn't have a license). One reason it took so long was the seizures frequently suffered by one of the daughters: they would stop and camp until she improved. North Carolina had few women drivers, so folks along the road would scatter when they saw Becky’s mother at the wheel. My father said he was at the Grubb place when John and his family showed up unannounced. It was hard on him; he had become like a son to his grandfather, and now he was displaced by the real son. Edwin Duncan, Sr. Edwin Duncan, Sr. (1905-1973, K89G-VD4) was born in Sparta, county seat of Alleghany County, in 1905. His father, Crockett (1873–1953, KF58-N16), was a farmer, businessman, and banker, having established the Bank of Sparta in 1902. In 1937, father and son established the Northwestern Bank through merger with another small bank. By the time Edwin Duncan died in 1973, it was the fourth largest bank in the state and had branches as far east as Durham. By then he was one of the leading figures in the western part of the state. As a young man fresh out of the university, Edwin almost decided to pursue a business career in the more accessible piedmont. In a newspaper profile in 1965, Duncan said, “‘there was no road down the mountain [from Sparta]. The nearest depot was at Galax. We took our trade, such as it was, to that Virginia town.’” According to the profile, when he traveled to the University of North Carolina, “going and coming often involved long hikes up and down the mountain from Doughton to Sparta.” As a result, “he had made up his mind to go to work in the city” in the lowlands. “‘I was in Winston-Salem looking for work,’ he says, ‘when my daddy soft-talked me into coming home. He told me the state was going to build a paved road up the mountain. He said business at home would improve.’.... This was 1925.” Young Edwin became a cashier in his father’s bank. It was a good decision for him. (Chester Davis, “Banker Ed Duncan Symbol of Northwest N.C. Growth," Winston Salem Journal, 4 April 1965) The year of Duncan’s decision, 1925, was the year before my father was born. As my memoirs of my father will show, Duncan’s decision to become a mountain banker and the way he conducted business figured significantly in my father’s professional career and in the circumstances leading to his death. Edwin Duncan, Sr., in 1965. He was president of the Northwestern Bank from 1958 until his retirement in 1971. (James Smith, “Retired Bank President, Former Senator Dies,” Winston-Salem Journal, 8 Oct 1973) Banmon Grayson, known professionally as G.B. Grayson. Mostly blind from an early age, Grayson was an influential fiddle player, singer, and song writer. As a young child, G.B. Grayson “left Ashe County for Laurel Bloomery, Tennessee, a very short move in miles, but one that gave him easier access to the Lee Highway, an important road that connected towns all along the Blue Ridge.” (“Music from the Lost Provinces: Old-Time String Bands from Ashe County, North Carolina, 1927 – 31”) A verse from Grayson's I've Always Been a Rambler captures the travel habits of folks in the Lost Provinces. They did not look to the prosperous, growing towns of the piedmont: I left old North Caroliner, to Marion I did go, Then on to Johnson City, gonna see this wide world o'er. Where money and work was plentiful and the girls treated me kind, The only object of my heart was the one I left behind. (Lyle Lofgren, “Remembering the Old Songs: I'VE ALWAYS BEEN A RAMBLER,” Inside Bluegrass, May 2005. This stanza is included in the performance on YouTube.) Thomas C. “Tam” Bowie. Although difficult, traveling east into piedmont North Carolina was necessary for some. Tam Bowie was a state legislator from Ashe County. He was one of many influential people from the northwest corner of the state who boosted the Good Roads movement in North Carolina in the 1920s; his biography in NCPedia credits him as being a leading promoter of the State Highway Act that “initiate[d] a $50 million road building program in North Carolina” (Thomas S. Morgan, “Bowie, Thomas Contee,” 1979). When the State Highway Act was being considered, officials and businessmen around the state began organizing campaigns to obtain funds to build and improve roads in their localities. Bowie helped organize and lead the campaign for the Lost Provinces in the seventh highway district. In a campaign meeting held in Wilkesboro in May 1921, he described “the great trouble with Ashe county”: “[H]er outlets are in Virginia and Tennessee and not North Carolina.… [T]he people of the county want to come to Wilkesboro; to reach North Carolina cities and towns now we must travel several hundred miles by rail.” He gave himself as an example: traveling to the meeting from his home in Ashe County, a distance of around forty miles, took two days by train. (“Largely Attended Road Meeting Held at Wilkesboro Yesterday,” Greensboro News and Record, 21 May 1921) Origin of “The Lost Provinces” For some time, I have known the counties beyond the Blue Ridge in the northwest corner of the state were the Lost Provinces. So far as I can remember, I assumed the term had been hallowed by time, like the State of Franklin or the Lost Colony. I haven’t heard the term in a good while, possibly because I don’t live there, possibly because the term has disappeared from popular usage. (It persists in journalism and on websites devoted to Ashe County history.) Recently I began to wonder how the term came about and when it was first applied to these counties. As we’ve seen, each area in the northwest corner of the state looked in a different direction for transportation and trade with the outside. In Alleghany, businessmen and travelers looked to the railhead in Galax, Virginia; in Ashe, they looked to West Jefferson and to Marion, Virginia (and later to Troutdale, Virginia); in Watauga, they looked to Johnson City, Tennessee. The area was, for ordinary business and practical purposes, lost to the rest of the state, so the term made a certain amount of sense. After running searches in newspapers.com, I’ve concluded that the term likely was popularized as a slogan of the Good Roads campaign in the northwestern counties. In fact, although I cannot yet prove it, I think the campaign likely deserves credit for first applying the term to these remote counties. Using newspapers.com, I searched “Lost Province(s)” for North Carolina newspapers from 1870 till 1930. Not surprisingly, I found that the term was most often used for the Alsace-Lorraine region, provinces on the border between France and Germany that were annexed by the Germans after the Franco-Prussian War of 1870; they were lost because they had been taken by a hostile country. Until the French regained them as part of the Treaty of Versailles in 1920, they remained a point of friction between the two countries and a frequent source of headlines and news stories even in North Carolina. In other words, just before the Good Roads boosters in the northwest corner of the state needed a memorable slogan to publicize their case, this term became available for a novel application. One of the first examples I found in this period was published in 1873 by a paper near the coast: “should Marshal MacMahon continue in power five years more, tremendous effort will be made to recover the lost provinces and restore the military prestige of France” (Our Living and Our Dead, New Bern, 24 Dec 1873). Over the years, the term was applied to other territories—China's lost Khanate of Kashgar (Pee Dee Herald, Wadesboro, 7 Aug 1878), the territories lost by Mexico to the US (Fayetteville Weekly Observer, 6 Dec 1883), the Sudan (The Central Express, Sanford, 12 Apr 1890), etc. But it usually referred to Alsace-Lorraine. In my search, I did not see the term applied to the northwestern counties until 1919—a bit of a challenge to my thesis, since the campaign did not seem to get underway until the following year. But the phrase was used in the context of the Good Roads movement in the northwest: “The ‘Lost Province’ engineers arrived last Friday evening for the purpose of making two preliminary surveys from North Wilkesboro” (North Wilkesboro Hustler, 4 July 1919). I suspect, but can’t prove, that the campaign was being organized behind the scenes and may already have found its slogan. In any case, the slogan seems to have come into general use beginning with a banquet in Winston-Salem, North Carolina, in November 1920. The purpose of the banquet was to support the Good Roads legislative program and to urge the allocation of funds to build and improve roads in Alleghany, Ashe, and Watauga counties. The keynote address was “Shall We Reclaim the Lost Provinces?” An article earlier in the week stated the Lost Provinces “will probably be the keynote for the plan that will be developed as a result of the meeting.” (The Sentinel, Winston-Salem, 23 Nov 1920). “Lost Provinces” was not mythos but marketing. At least some understood that the term had been borrowed from a foreign context. In late December 1920, in a story headlined “Our Lost Provinces,” the Greensboro Record, wrote “North Carolina's Alsace and Lorraine were not torn from her by any foreign invader, but merely allowed to drift away through neglect” and because of “the mighty barrier” of the Blue Ridge. Perhaps “Lost Provinces” also had the advantage of echoing the Lost Colony; the failed attempt to establish a permanent English settlement on Roanoke Island in the 16th century was a continuing topic of interest. Mystery and romance attached to the colonists’ unknown fate; perhaps “Lost Provinces” was an attempt to transfer some of that mystique to the plight of the remote mountain counties. “Lost Provinces” was not used in The Hand-book of North Carolina: The Farms, Orchards & Vineyards, the Forests, Mines and Factories, a 333-page work published by the state in 1893. The handbook mentions the Lost Colony twice. It notes the remoteness of Ashe County, though with undue optimism ("the inaccessibility of Ashe County will soon be a thing of the past,” 319). Indeed, the entire mountain region is described as being, with some exceptions, “inaccessible to market” (7) and “inaccessible to transportation” (6). Still, semantically at least, the mountain counties were neither provinces nor lost. But by the time the State Ship and Water Transportation Commission issued its report in 1924, the term had, as shown above, entered the lexicon of policy makers. [1] ID numbers and birth and date dates for family members are from FamilySearch.org.
[2] In the late 20’s, a young cousin named Rex Crouse (about 1913 – 1929, 9KGY-LKW) left the mountains in a similar way. He first went to West Virginia to work in the mines, but “I got tired of working in the dark so I just saved me up about $75.00 and sold every thing I had and started out on the Highway and flaged every Car that passed me.” Like John R. Grubb, he ended up in California, but he never left: he and his flight instructor were killed when the plane they were in power dove into the ground.—J.S. Absher, “The Letters of Rex Lee Crouse: A Sad Family Story of No Importance,” unpublished. Posted 3 March 2026; revised 5 March 2016. Elevations are from online US topographic maps. Current travel times and distances are from Google Maps.
2 Comments
Phillip Absher
3/4/2026 07:34:14 pm
Stan,
Reply
3/5/2026 10:47:23 am
Thanks for sharing this interesting stories and info. I was planning some minor corrections and one significant addition to the post. I'm gong to add the travel time by horse and wagon to Wilkes and back.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. Archives
October 2026
Categories |